It’s My Notebook.
AI Detox

How to Write Without AI: A Gentle Five-Step Practice

A short, kind guide to keeping some of your writing fully your own, with an honest look at what the early research does and does not say.

21 November 2026 · 5 min read · It’s My Notebook

A candle beside an open blank notebook and pencil, suggesting a calm way to write without AI

There is a small moment, just after you open a blank page, when a tool is ready to finish your sentence. It is quick and often helpful. It is also the moment when the thinking would have started.

This is a short, practical guide to how to write without AI, not forever and not as a protest, but as a regular practice. Five steps, none of them hard. First, a look at why anyone might bother.

Why try to write without AI at all

Nobody has proven that AI makes people less intelligent, and it is worth saying so plainly. What exists so far is early, small and suggestive. Three things are worth knowing.

Memory likes being the author. A large meta-analysis of generation-effect experiments, covering 126 articles and 310 experiments, found that people remembered things they produced themselves about ten percentage points better than things they only read. The experiments mostly used words and short items, not essays or journals, so treat it as a clue and not a verdict.

One early brain study. In 2025, MIT Media Lab researchers posted the preprint Your Brain on ChatGPT. Fifty-four participants wrote essays with a chatbot, with a search engine, or with no tools, while EEG recorded their brain activity. The no-tools group showed the strongest connectivity, the chatbot group the weakest, and chatbot users found it harder to quote their own essays. Only 18 people completed the final session, and the work had not been peer reviewed when it appeared. Scientific American quotes outside experts who note the small sample, the single twenty-minute task, and the fact that more brain connectivity is not simply better. The lead author told WBUR the results do not mean people were "stupid."

Confidence matters. A CHI 2025 survey of 319 knowledge workers from Microsoft Research and Carnegie Mellon, The Impact of Generative AI on Critical Thinking, found that higher confidence in the AI went with less critical thinking, while higher confidence in oneself went with more. The data were self-reported and correlational, and The Register points out that most of the authors work at a company that sells AI tools.

None of this says "stop." It says that your own thinking is a muscle, and muscles like being used. So here is a way to use it.

Step 1: Decide what is yours

Pick one kind of writing that stays unassisted. A journal entry, a letter to a friend, the first paragraph of anything. Make the decision before you open anything, because deciding in the moment tends to favor the shortcut.

The lead MIT researcher suggests a similar question. Before reaching for a chatbot, ask whether you need it or just want the shortcut. Some days you will need it, and that is fine.

Step 2: Start with ten minutes and a plain page

Paper is ideal, but a bare text editor with no suggestions works too. Set a timer for ten minutes. Short is the point. A small commitment is one you will actually keep.

If you like the feel of ink, our look at what research says about writing by hand is a good companion.

Step 3: Write the rough version first

Let the first draft be clumsy. Write the half-formed sentence, the repeated word, the thought that wanders. You are not producing something to hand over. You are finding out what you think.

This is the part a tool is best at hiding, because a tidy paragraph appears and you never see your own mess.

Step 4: Stay with the stuck moment

At some point you will stall. The next sentence will not come. Wait. Look out of the window. Write "I do not know how to say this" and keep going from there.

The MIT researcher says learning needs some challenge, and that is exactly what this is. Discomfort here is not a sign you are doing it wrong. It is the work.

Step 5: Invite tools in on your terms

Afterwards, if you want help with spelling, structure or a second opinion, ask for it. The order matters: your thinking first, the tool second. In the MIT follow-up session, the people who had written without tools first and then switched to the chatbot showed strong brain activity and better recall. That was only 18 participants in total, so hold it lightly, but it fits the idea of thinking first and asking second.

A simple check: can you say, from memory, what your piece argues, and could you quote a line from it? If yes, it is yours.

Frequently asked questions

Does using AI to write make you less intelligent?

There is no proof of that. The early studies are small and narrow, and the MIT lead author has said her results should not be read that way. What the research suggests is that effortful thinking is worth protecting.

How often should I write without AI?

There is no studied number. Ten minutes a few times a week is a realistic place to start, and you can adjust from there.

Is it wrong to ever use AI for writing?

No. This practice is about balance and about keeping some writing fully your own, not about avoiding tools altogether.

A private notebook, locked with your own passphrase, is one quiet place for that kind of writing to live.

Sources

A page, just for you.

Let your own words find a home. Your first 20,000 words are free, and your pages are encrypted on your device.

Try the notebook